I am reading a book at the moment. An actual book made of paper that is new and that I bought for me! Something I haven't done for a couple of years at least. It is called "Unqualified Education" and is by Gareth Lewis. It is the sequel to his book "One to One" that I first read before S was one. He talks about strewing (but he doesn't call it that) and about making life at home interesting, sparkly at fun. I guess he is in the radical home maker camp.
I really enjoyed his first book but for two things. The first being that he uses margarine to make cakes and the second being that I felt, come age 11, he rather left things hanging as to future direction so great that there is now a follow up.
In the introduction he writes
"Since writing One to One I have been accused of being both too extremely anti-school and too supportive of parents who do send their children to school. Surprisingly perhaps both these allegations came from home education groups."
Freeze frame! That is like the story of me over the past few weeks before I stepped aside from running the local home ed group (which, by the way, seems to be running very well in my absence.
I am interested in the later phase of home education at the moment because I like to read about ideas for the future and also because I am aware that so many people give up in the teen zone. Come age 14 or 15 those that are sticking with it are significantly smaller in number and, in a sense, it becomes self fulfilling. Teens like to hang out with other teens and if there aren't any to hang out with the world can seem a lonely place.
Of course I will only be able to understand this age when I have lived it myself and several people have kindly pointed out to me recently how my complete lack of real life experience in this are means I shouldn't say anything at all. However, people said the same to me when S was 10 months old and I told them she wouldn't be going to school so I am undeterred.
I may not have first hand knowledge but I have run a local group for nearly half a decade and I can see the patterns emerging, I am not sure if that makes me qualified to comment, but that is okay I am only trying to see the ways to make things best for my family. Although each family situation is totally unique there are consistent themes and trends and the reasons people stop home education do show patterns.
Ahead of all other reasons in the number one spot, miles ahead of its nearest rivals has to be Unsupportive Dad, and, to a lesser extent close family and grandparents. He might come in different guises but the core issues are the same. It is hard for adults who did not have their needs met as children to meet the needs of their own children. The Daddy One in our family couldn't be more supportive, he never grumbles if the paints are still on the table when tea is ready and is totally 100% there for his children in a way that his peers find impossible to comprehend. From when he joined me in giving up alcohol for all three of my pregnancies along side me whilst other fathers-to-be were celebrating the arrival of a designated driver for the next 9 months I knew he was going to be different!
Other reasons feature highly too: finances, not really letting go of the deep seated idea that academic success equals superior monetary gain equals happiness. but I'll save those for another blog post.
I am enjoying the book so far and feel we have very strong foundations to carry this right the way through. I'll let you know more when I have finished it and if you have any good book suggestions for older children and home ed do please let me know.
15 comments:
I've just bought this book and I'm reading it too !
Didn't read his first one, came into HE too late for it to be relevant for us but this one is thought provoking.
Although his take seems to be not going down the exam route (which we are doing, in certain subjects) in every other respect it's extremely useful....after all there is so much more to an 'educated' and happy life that paper qualifications. I'm hoping to find some good pointers !
Is it still strewing if you lob the book in a high trajectory over the
boys head so it slaps down on the table in front of him?
I think I am into strewing but called it 'Stacking the book shelf',
and surfng the web too, but I think 'strewing' has a passive connotation which doesn't apply here. Oh well... :)
"I am not sure if that makes me qualified to comment"
LOL.
I am still reading, that's a lot of experience. Are the 'shush!'
people likely to comment here?
Otoh, I don't think we'll ever be able to properly experience being a
home educated teen, unless you were one once of course.
" ...not really letting go of the deep seated idea that academic
success equals superior monetary gain equals happiness."
Yeah...this one can be tricky. I'd like to settle for access to
academias labs and girls frankly, or boys if that's the way either of
mine goes.
But regarding information and tuition, I'm convinced that most of
academia is bloated and a rubbish deal.
I think I've got the first book, and I doubt I'd spend money on the
second, unless it was very cheap in a charity shop so this kind of
post is useful for me. Does the book have a wikipedia page do you know Katie?
Sorry Mr Lewis...it's the zeitgeist.. :)
I've a booky blogpost coming up, but it's not finished yet, and I'm
thinking of plastering it with ads, so it might take a bit longer to
do.
Stuart
Love this post, but can't add anything as I am also unqualified to comment! :D Will prob buy the book, though, as bought One-to-One when my oldest was only a baby :D
Thanks for all the comments guys.
Stuart - I know a handful of second generation home edders who were home ed and are now home edding and it is interesting to hear their angle and what happened to them and their friends etc.
Strewing can take many forms - there are some good links on here http://www.sandradodd.com/strewing
This is Mr Lewis' website
http://www.freedom-in-education.co.uk/
Interesting post and now I'll hafta find that book. We are unschoolers in the US and our kids are currently 19 and 17-1/2. At over 60, I am a stay-at-home unschooling dad who has never fit into... well, pretty much anything normal! (grin)
Sandra Dodd's site and Joyce Fetteroll's are always goo dreading.
Hi there, thanks for the comment. Love the photo of you on your boat :) Enjoy Sandra's site, we actually had Sandra to stay with us for a few days back in June whilst she was in the UK for a conference. I'll check out Joyce.
Here is the conference write up where I raise a laugh from Sandra by saying we are not text book unschoolers!
http://thegallivanters.blogspot.com/2011/06/little-conference-in-london-11611.html
Ah, yes, I remember Sandra talking about that conference. She and my wife, Ronnie, have been online together forever and we've been with Sandra and her family a few times in real life at conferences. We also love Schuyler and David Waynforth and their kids. They've visited us here in Seattle and because of the geographic reality, we don't get to see them very often.
Ronnie and her friend Mary Gold, who is responsible for the LIFE is Good Unschooling Conference, will be in London during the first week of November to go to a James concert and they've talked to Schuyler about getting together while they're there. Our younger daughter, Chloe, attended Summerhill School for a term a few years ago and Ronnie and Chloe both loved their time in England, so Ronnie is excited to visit again next month.
I'll hafta spend a little time catching up on your blog; I enjoy your writing style.
Thank-You. Just curious how you found me. Was it the #unschooling hashtag on twitter?
Ps The Daddy One has been to Houston Texas on business in the past. I am considering tagging us along for the ride next time.
I found this blog because Stuart Dunstan linked this post on Google+, which I joined recently. I don't do twitter.
My biased opinion: If you're gonna visit the US, almost anywhere is better than Texas; however, if you're going mostly or partly on a corporate account, then Houston is wonderful. (wink!) The weather can be brutal in the Summer but I suspect you're aware of that.
I think I have found you on G+ (which I really like but it is a little underpopulated)
yes, I'd be in New York or California in a heartbeat.......but if we could use it as a base. It is the George Bush connection that deter me but I was a Dallas fan back in the day ;-)
Yes, we are mutually circled on Google+. (grin)
I'm so sorry to hear of your (former) support for Dallas. Having been born and raised in New Orleans, I am an eternal Saints fan; but living in Seattle, (Ronnie and) I have season tickets to the Seahawks.
You may pity me now.
New Orleans hey! My children's best home educated friends originate from New Orleans. This is they http://myagainstthegrain.blogspot.com/
They now live about 15 miles from us and know we know all about king cakes.
Not to quote Disney but it's a small world, after all! Tell the former New Orleanians I say, "Where ya'at, cher!"
Post a Comment